i’ve been reading Dan, of According to Dan. Currently i’m in the process of reading all of his archives. If you don’t read Dan, you should, (Amber too) because his blog is just fantastic. His tales are funny, sexy, and often thought provoking. The thought provoking leads me to this post.
Way back in October he did a post about an Oprah show that he watched. Basically there was this idiot asshole guy who was a TOTAL jerk to his wife and (here’s the kicker) was stupid enough to let the Oprah shows producers put cameras up in his house. So the whole world found out what an asshole this guy was. (Go Oprah!) Dan’s problem with the show was that there were some very skewed statistics stating that 1 in 3 women are in emotionally abusive relationships.
And, Dan is right. These stats are skewed. Badly. Here is my personal experience with this.
my regular readers know i am interning at a woman’s shelter. When i was coming up for the interview for this job, i did as much research on the facility as i could. They have a website, so of course i poured over it, devouring as much information as i could. The site features a “Danger Quiz” designed to let women know if they are in an abusive relationship. There are 26 questions. For each question you must choose an answer from often, sometimes, hardly ever and never. When i answered them the first time, honestly, this flashed on my screen: Severely abusive: Get help – things are out of control! Want to know the only ones i didn’t put never for?
Is he ever rude to your friends? my answer was hardly ever, because i have one friend who is a bit of a bitch, and every so often she crosses the line and J tells her off.
Do you ever feel alone, as if there was nobody close to you to talk to? my answer was sometimes… and honestly i think if you never feel like this… you are probably whining everyone in your life to death. This feeling is a part of life… doesn’t mean its true, you just feel that way sometimes.
Do you argue about bills and money? my answer was sometimes… when you are broke all the damn time, you fight about money. Another fact of life.
Do you argue about having children or how to raise them? my answer again was sometimes. And, again, i feel that this is a problem that is just going to exist. When two people both care that deeply about something sometimes they are going to have differing opinions that are worth fighting about.
Does he ever throw or break things when he is angry? my answer was hardly ever. Since we have been together J has murdered a fan and broke an alarm clock. He also lost his temper with his car once a long time ago and hit the windshield (that he had just broken accidentally) with a ratchet repeatedly. This is childish behavior, but we can’t all be saints now can we? And, if he wants to fuck up his own stuff, that’s his problem.
Has he ever been in trouble with the police? my answer was hardly ever. Once a pretty long time ago. And, it wasn’t for beating on anyone.
So you guys know i think J hung the moon. He is not abusive and is, in fact, a very loving and fan-freaking-tastic husband. These people are full of shit.
So for shits and giggles i went back and changed all of my answers to never. The result? Moderately abusive: Watch out things may get worse!
WTF??
Now, i know that they are probably thinking that if you took the test something must be wrong. But, still. Why are they telling all and sundry that their relationship is at best moderately abusive??? This is very fucked up. This is my problem with the battered woman’s movement.
Now, i’m not saying there shouldn’t be a battered woman’s movement. There should be. i’ve been working in that shelter. i’ve seen clients that have been folded, stapled, and mutilated. Its horrible. Hell, i’ve been folded, stapled, and mutilated by assholes in my life. But, the bottom line is that going hysterically overboard and forming this opinion that all men are bad is just utterly stupid, and worse, unhelpful.
And, it bugs me that as a society, instead of trying to fix the problems of our women, we are trying to foist them on our men too. Stuff like men suffering from poor self esteem because of those 15 extra pounds, teenage boys worrying obsessively about their complexion while they buy overpriced moisturizing creams and cleansers just drives me nuts. The self esteem of the average woman is not that great. Yes, that’s a sweeping generalization, but i’ve done quite a bit of research on it for papers i wrote in college, and while i don’t have the facts and figures in front of me to support it right now, its a true statement. That sucks, its a terrible thing. But, are we doing things to make these women feel better? NO! We are attacking the self-esteem of the men now! This is stupid. Making the men miserable will not make the women feel better.
Yes, you should be concerned about your weight for your health. But, dammit, you should not have to feel like a worthless fat slob if you are overweight. You should not be fired from your job for it. Those assholes at PETA should not make a list of fat male celebrities to bash because they made a list of fat female celebrities. They should fucking quit doing it!
We are going to hell in a hand basket folks!